This is How I Would Fix the NASCAR All-Star Race

This morning, NASCAR introduced the format for the upcoming Clash at Daytona. Personally, I’m a big fan of it. I think it gets back to the simple nature that brought so much prestige to NASCAR‘s exhibition races in the first place.

But sitting there in Mid-May, a week before one of the biggest races and one of the biggest race weekends of the entire calendar year, sits an enigma.

What used to be one of the most prestigious dates on the calendar is now something that doesn’t seem to matter anymore.

The All-Star Race.

20 to 25 of the best stock car drivers on the planet dueling it out for $1 million. At its core, it’s a very simple premise that doesn’t need to be messed with. But like a lot of things, NASCAR messed with it.

We are a long way removed from the glory that was “One Hot Night”. A race that once had more identity than almost any other race on the calendar aside from the Crown Jewels, now feels meaningless. Its identity, long gone.

So I’m gonna fix it. Hear me out, this is an outlandish idea, but I think you will like it.

If you’ve been watching NASCAR for at least 10 to 15 years, then you may be familiar with “Denny Hamlin’s Short Track Showdown”. And if you’re not, allow me to enlighten you. From 2008 to 2015 and again in 2018, Denny Hamlin put on an exhibition race in super late models at various short tracks around his home state of Virginia. These races were for charity, primarily supporting the Denny Hamlin Foundation.

These races featured Cup Series Superstars like Hamlin himself, the late, great Kyle Busch, and 3-Time Cup Series Champion Tony Stewart, among others; it also gave a spotlight to young up-and-comers. Bubba Wallace competed in several of these events; 2-time Truck Series Champion Ben Rhodes was a competitor, and 2-time Truck Series Race Winner Nick Sanchez competed in 2018. It even attracted a few international names like Pietro Fittipaldi.

If I were NASCAR, that’s the blueprint I would go for to fix the All-Star race. 30-40 of the best stock car racers in the country going at it in super late models for $1 million.

Who’s Eligible?

As far as who would be eligible to compete in this race, this is how the entry list would be set:

  1. Every Cup Series Race Winner since the beginning of the previous season
  2. Every active Cup Series champion who has NOT won a race since the beginning of the previous season
  3. The defending O’Reilly Auto Parts Series Champion
  4. The defending FedEx Freight Truck Series Champion
  5. The defending Champion of every CARS Tour division
  6. The defending Champion of all three ARCA divisions
  7. The defending Whelen Modified Tour Champion
  8. The defending SMART Modified Tour Champion
  9. The defending Snowball Derby Winner

Here is a hypothetical entry list to provide an example for you:

*Based on the lead-up to the 2026 NASCAR All-Star Race

  • #1 Ross Chastain
  • #2 Austin Cindric
  • #2a Jesse Love
  • #3 Austin Dillon
  • #5 Kyle Larson
  • #6 Brad Keselowski
  • #6a Ben Maier
  • #7 Luke Baldwin
  • #8 Kyle Busch
  • #08 Jace Hansen
  • #9 Chase Elliott
  • #11 Denny Hamlin
  • #12 Ryan Blaney
  • #12a Brenden Queen
  • #19 Chase Briscoe
  • #20 Christopher Bell
  • #21 Josh Berry
  • #22 Joey Logano
  • #23 Bubba Wallace
  • #24 William Byron
  • #29 Landen Lewis
  • #45 Tyler Reddick
  • #50 Trevor Huddleston
  • #51 Stephen Nasse
  • #64 Austin Beers
  • #67 Corey Heim
  • #77 Carson Hocevar
  • #79 Isaac Kitzmiller
  • #97 Shane van Gisbergen

This criteria would give drivers, young and old, who have been making a name for themselves on the regional circuits, a chance to show what they’ve really got in equal equipment against the best in the business. It also opens the door for drivers who have made a career racing in regional ARCA, Modified and Late Model Tours to have a shot at not just big money, but life-changing money. And on a national stage, no less.

It showcases the best of the best and the best of the rest all at the same time. It showcases what the sport looks like today and what it will look like tomorrow.

The Format

Now, with all that out of the way, what would the race itself look like?

Here’s what I’m thinking:

  • A rotation of tracks across North Carolina, Virginia, and Tennessee (North Wilkesboro, Hickory, South Boston, Richmond, Nashville Fairgrounds, etc.) Part of the beauty of the All-Star Race is keeping it close to home.
  • The full field will get 1 hour of practice in the early afternoon.
  • A random pill draw will set the starting lineup for the heat races.
  • The heat races will set the starting lineup for the feature event.
  • Depending on the size of the track, the feature race distance would be somewhere between 175 and 250 laps with a competition caution somewhere in the middle.
  • Every team would be given two sets of Goodyear tires (this is a NASCAR race after all). One to start the race on and one to put on at the competition caution.
  • The winner gets $1 million and automatic entry into the following year’s All-Star race.
  • Second place gets $100,000.
  • Third place gets $75,000.
  • Everyone else gets $50,000 for starting the race.

A Name Change

You may not fully agree with this, but I think in order for the All-Star Race to regain its identity, it should no longer be called the “All-Star Race”, addition by subtraction if you will.

Unless you have completely shut the period of time between January 1, 2020 and December 31, 2021 out of your memory (which I would not blame you for doing at all), you probably remember when NASCAR did the iRacing Pro Invitational. An exhibition series that took place on the virtual racing platform, iRacing. Many drivers, both active and former, took part in 150-200 Mile races for charity. It was a hit during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic but fell off soon after once the sport started to return to normal.

That is where I am pulling the name for this new and improved “All-Star Race” from. In this hypothetical universe, NASCAR’s All-Star race will now be known as:

The NASCAR Pro Invitational

You may not fully agree with this idea, and that’s fine. It is, after all, just an idea. My proposing this to you is nothing more than a fan trying to come up with an idea to make the sport that he loves better.

Leave a Reply